I’ve noticed some concern and skepticism about the Monday 6/28 debut of ABC Family’s new series “Huge“, about 7 teens who spend their summer at weight loss camp.
Yep, the title sounds controversial even thought it’s actually based on a well known book by Sasha Paley.
Yep, the premise sounds potentially exploitative.
Why do we have to watch a show about overweight kids at a weight loss camp?
Why can’t we just see seven diversely shaped teenagers who take on life, love, and the pursuit of unlimited text time with friends?
Well…because that seems too close to everyday. And seven teens struggling with their weight set against the backdrop of a weight loss camp is compelling television.
We have to remember this is TV. And TV has to be visual and flashy – enough to capture your attention away from roaming to your laptop, cell phone, iPad or remote control. Enough to compel you to tune in multiple times, therefore getting ratings and guaranteeing that shows survival.
TV deals with extremes. And people like to see extremes. “Fear Factor”? Soap Operas?
Hello, one of the most popular reality shows is called “EXTREME” Home Makeover.
Not “Moderate and Balanced for Your Budget” Home Makeover.
Believe me, I am immensely sensitive, critical and tuned in to the extreme (and often damaging) messaging about body image that the media presents…especially to teenagers. But I think we have an opportunity here that I don’t want us to miss.
I’ve been a leader in the Confidence Community™ for over 16 years, my work is dedicated to creating a nation of confident women and girls. And that’s just not lip service – it’s my life. It’s who I am. It’s what I’ve overcome and what I dream about every single day. I dream of a world where women and men are truly free from body hatred and dieting tyranny. Where little girls aren’t obsessed with their looks and women earn their fare wage in the workplace. A world where we pay teachers more than the reality stars who flash their private parts whenever someone pulls out a camera.
But I am also a passionate and realistic Actionist® living and working within Hollywood. It was my choice 10 years ago, to move to the heart of the entertainment (and fantasy making) industry to create a platform within mainstream media that could tell a different story about the lives of women and girls.
I love the power of TV and all media to connect and communicate to a vast audience. I love that it creates a common touch point between total strangers who can all share the same recorded moment at the same time. And I love that it stirs up conversation. Good, bad, right or wrong, when media can inspire authentic communication that really geeks me out.
When thinking about this show we also have to remember that TV isn’t a substitute for a social movement. We can use the media to move messaging but it can’t replace the every day action we take to change the real issues we face. “Huge” in particular is not designed to be a social service campaign. It is designed to be entertaining. That doesn’t mean we can’t be thoughtful or critical about the issues it confronts or the emotions it will stir up. But let’s not forget it is a TV show and that shouldn’t usurp a real conversation about these issues with the people in your life.
My hope is that “Huge” could also end up allowing us to move beyond the obvious extremes and move us into a world where these teen characters are actually going to give voice to an invisible population. It’s rare that we ever get to see heavier teens being the stars of their own lives on TV shows. They are usually relegated to the roles of “side kick”, “butt of joke”, and “sloppy gross guy”. Yet on this show, these characters get to be real teenagers…dealing with quests for popularity, unrequited love, feelings of inferiority, and a hope that people will look past their exterior and really see them.
Those aren’t plus size issues. Those are universal issues.
And following other ground breaking extremely stereotypical shows that audiences had to sit through before we became more comfortable with African Americans on our TV’s (“The Jeffersons”) or Gays and Lesbians in our living rooms (“Queer as Folk” anyone?) we will also have to bear the first image of Nikki Blonksy showing off in her swimsuit to reveal not just a size 6 thigh (Hollywood’s typical version of ‘fat’) but real honest to goodness cellulite.
It’s a shocking. I won’t lie. I have already screened the first two episodes and that scene with Nikki stopped me in my tracks. It stirred in me a lot of mixed feelings about my own relationship to weight, size and seeing it on screen. And that’s good. It should do that. But that shock only lasted for a moment before I became pretty fascinated as I watched Nikki’s character “Will” give voice to the inner debate many of us have had “I want to get healthy and be a better version of myself but I want to do it for me. Not because someone is forcing me to change”.
To me this is nowhere near as disturbing as the “Biggest Loser“ where people go from 500 pounds to 100 pounds in the span of just a few weeks. However, the difference here is that “Huge” isn’t a reality show (or pretending to be one). It’s a fictional series written by two very compelling writers, the Mom/Daughter duo Winnie Holzman and Savannah Dooley. Holzman, thoroughly gets teen angst and is the writer of one of my all time favorite shows “My So Called Life”.
So I am more than willing to deal with all my mixed feelings about the show and it’s subject matter to watch how the stories unfold this summer. I hope we don’t write it off too soon and stop from seeing the heart that I think emerges more in episode 2.
Because I am committed to creating dialogue about this show, I have created a conversation guide to help you begin a dialogue with your students, children, spouse, friends or blogging community after viewing “Huge”.
Everyone consumes media through the lens of their own life experiences and I have no doubt that there will be a million different reactions to the story lines based on your own views and background. But for Actionists® out there who say they want to see more diversity on TV – this could also be a chance to really make some noise.
Sometimes we have to first work with these extremes in order to eventually normalize them and build upon them. And then hopefully we have a plethora of programs that feature diverse women’s stories regardless of their body size.
Yours in Action,
Jess